4.22: adda/type/const/for shared-link parameters:
. what is the diff'tween {const, rom}?
and did you notice that in formal params,
where rom is needed,
this const syntax is not very applicable ?
. the reason for being concerned with rom
is that people would like to know
whether they can safely pass a reference .
. this should be handled as it is in Ada:
it is safe unless the parameter is
specifically marked as out-mode .
. so the question then becomes,
what is an intuitive symbol for out-mode?
. ada's goto enclosure has been written about before;
and out-mode mode param's are like goto's;
because, they are transfering control to
some surprising places .
todo:
. how was it shown
where the out-mode is happening?
eg, for an array of pointers to strings,
is the array being modified (dangling pointer risk)
or are the strings being modified ?
the out-mode syntax needs to
make this distinction easy to express .
. what if the caller provides a shared link;
and, while the caller meant for the ref'
to provide the value it represented
at the time of the call,
in fact it will be changing dynamically,
because even though the caller is suspended
the caller's co.programs are still modifying the link;
therefore:
when a link represents a value
then the shared value needs a soft-locking system:
it doesn't prevent co.programs from writing
but requires the first writer
to ask the system for a lock-removal service;
in doing that,
the system sees who the lock belongs to
and copies the current value .
. if it knows the lock owner is going to be quick
it can just high-prioritize that call,
and suspend the unlocker until then .
. this is a lot efficiency glue
so the system needs to know at call time
whether an input is large eno' to link to,
since copying makes life much simpler .
4.22: mis.adda/type/const/for non-parameters:
. while const's for param's are not an issue
(see notes about rom above)
[@] adda/type/const/for shared-link parameters
const's for symbol declarations are very useful .
. I've had problems finding a const operator
(below) [@] mis.adda/uniqueness operator
but, having the need restricted to non-parameters
makes the search moot, I thought,
as const's can be initialized with a label
rather than an assignment operator;
nevertheless,
what if uninitialized, but
intending to assign later only once?
then a const symbol would enforce
only one assignment .
. just as math uses (someone!)
to mean (exactly one),
the type system could use (type!)
to mean not just (some
of the values from this type)
but instead (exactly one
of the values from this type
will be used here).
4.22: mis.adda/uniqueness operator:
. a convenient symbol for rom
is the same as for unique,
since rom maintains a unique value across times .
. notice though, that
when I chose (!) for unique
it was because math uses it for the
unique existence quantifier;
but when (!) is used alone, without (some),
math defines it as factorial;
and what does that have to do with unique?
( recall factorial:
x! = *(^i: i= 1..x) -- very multiplicative!
) . in both of these math cases,
it matches the usual english meaning:
(very *) .
. in the case of (some!),
(exactly one) is a very useful version of
(some one) because,
(mapping to exactly one)
is an essential characteristic of functions
-- one of math's foundations .
. intuitively the name could come from
feeling very responsible:
ie, if "(some one) did it
then there is a degree of anonymity,
but if exactly (!) one member is responsible
then that one member is
very much the reason for the season .
2011-04-30
integrating types and dimensions
4.22: todo.adda/urgent/types integrated with dimensions:
just as 9.81 m/s/s
means 9.81 * m/s/s
f(x) is a shorthand for
f @ (x);
thus, space is an overloaded infix operator
meaning either a multiply or an apply .
. it is unambiguous because of the
specific places that an apply is expected .
. symbols must declare whether they expect an arg;
therefore what follows such a symbol
must be either {arg, terminator};
otherwise, it can expect either
{ infix
, multiply`factor or dimensional
, terminator}.
todo:
still need to flesh out
how to dimension things
and declare dimensions
--
. "(dimensional) refers to numeric types:
any renaming of a numeric type
must be a dimension because it implies
a numeric amount of a certain substance;
3 tsp substance
-- tsp is a unit of volume;
hence the declaration:
( tsp.vol: 4.92892159 ml )
-- many things can be measured in 3 ways:
unit counts, volumes, and weights of masses .
. in addition to type being a special type,
there is a special class of primary dimensions:
{ volume, mass, length, time,
, electric intensity
, thermal intensity
, radiation intensity }.
just as 9.81 m/s/s
means 9.81 * m/s/s
f(x) is a shorthand for
f @ (x);
thus, space is an overloaded infix operator
meaning either a multiply or an apply .
. it is unambiguous because of the
specific places that an apply is expected .
. symbols must declare whether they expect an arg;
therefore what follows such a symbol
must be either {arg, terminator};
otherwise, it can expect either
{ infix
, multiply`factor or dimensional
, terminator}.
todo:
still need to flesh out
how to dimension things
and declare dimensions
--
. "(dimensional) refers to numeric types:
any renaming of a numeric type
must be a dimension because it implies
a numeric amount of a certain substance;
3 tsp substance
-- tsp is a unit of volume;
hence the declaration:
( tsp.vol: 4.92892159 ml )
-- many things can be measured in 3 ways:
unit counts, volumes, and weights of masses .
. in addition to type being a special type,
there is a special class of primary dimensions:
{ volume, mass, length, time,
, electric intensity
, thermal intensity
, radiation intensity }.
unique pointers
4.21: news.adda/dstr/unique pointer:
. the idea behind the unique pointer
is that they can be safely moved between threads
and they never require locking;
--
[. I first saw this idea in ms`singularity;
the msg's are instantanious because
they involve moving
only a shared heap pointer
rather than a record between process heaps .
problems with maintenance:
. after a move for a unique pointer,
the source has to be set to null?
--
I thought a simpler idea would be
a handle to a record (pointer, owner ID );
and then, in order to use the pointer,
you had to set the owner ID to
the process you were passing it to .
. anyone using it would first have to check for
whether they actually owned it at the moment .
once they were done with it
they would hand it to the system (ID=0)
or they could communicate it to a co.process .]
making concurrent programming safer:
. he proposes to do this by
extending the type system.
. two major challenges in multithreaded programming
are identified as:
Avoiding races -- approachable,
Preventing deadlocks -- pie in the sky.
. his main reference is:
Object Types against Races (pdf):
. Cormac Flanagan and Mart ́ Abadi .
. the idea behind the unique pointer
is that they can be safely moved between threads
and they never require locking;
--
[. I first saw this idea in ms`singularity;
the msg's are instantanious because
they involve moving
only a shared heap pointer
rather than a record between process heaps .
problems with maintenance:
. after a move for a unique pointer,
the source has to be set to null?
--
I thought a simpler idea would be
a handle to a record (pointer, owner ID );
and then, in order to use the pointer,
you had to set the owner ID to
the process you were passing it to .
. anyone using it would first have to check for
whether they actually owned it at the moment .
once they were done with it
they would hand it to the system (ID=0)
or they could communicate it to a co.process .]
making concurrent programming safer:
. he proposes to do this by
extending the type system.
. two major challenges in multithreaded programming
are identified as:
Avoiding races -- approachable,
Preventing deadlocks -- pie in the sky.
. his main reference is:
Object Types against Races (pdf):
. Cormac Flanagan and Mart ́ Abadi .
This paper investigates an approach for
statically preventing race conditions in an oop language.
The setting of this work is a variant of
Gordon and Hankin’s concurrent object calculus.
We enrich that calculus with a form of
dependent object types
that enables us to verify that threads
invoke and update methods only after
acquiring appropriate locks.
We establish that well-typed programs
do not have race conditions.
Labels:
adda,
cstr,
safe pointers
2011-03-31
dsm means full code generation
3.7: news.adda/domain-specific modeling and full code generation:
. when you hear about thousand-fold
increases in productivity from applying
industrial-age engineering techniques
it is from the use of domain-specific modeling
being the facilitator of full code generation .
. it's like the idea of a module-connection language
extended to generate code for
not just the connections but the entire app .
. it's like domain-specific support libraries
extended to include control structures
-- and anything else you need in order to
keep your hands out of source code [3.31:
(in contrast to Literate Programming,
which eases the transition between dsm and
the chosen manual code generation) .]
ieeexplore.ieee.org`Computer 2002/(pdf)
Model-integrated computing (MIC):
finding the fundamentals like math does
but in an elegant unified local-friendly language . ]
-- . the article was seen here first: softwaretechnews.thedacs.com,
and authored by metacase.com
todo:
how completely can adda merge with this?
get more .edu data about what this is .
. weed out dsl's:
Domain-Specific Languages: An Annotated Bibliography
. the key to productivity is full code generation;
that leaves you with what the modeling lang' should be;
well, starting from scratch then,
being dom'specific helps;
but you can go quite far with a general-purpose lang'
that offers user-defined control structures .
. when you hear about thousand-fold
increases in productivity from applying
industrial-age engineering techniques
it is from the use of domain-specific modeling
being the facilitator of full code generation .
. it's like the idea of a module-connection language
extended to generate code for
not just the connections but the entire app .
. it's like domain-specific support libraries
extended to include control structures
-- and anything else you need in order to
keep your hands out of source code [3.31:
(in contrast to Literate Programming,
which eases the transition between dsm and
the chosen manual code generation) .]
ieeexplore.ieee.org`Computer 2002/(pdf)
Model-integrated computing (MIC):
--[ . this is a reminder that adda is supposed to be. To be useful, a reusable framework for
creating domain-specific design environments
must have a meta-metamodel lang
ie, generic enough to be applicable to
a wide range of domains.
meta-metamodeling:
as defined by math fundamentals of
logic, set, category, quantification, ...:
containment,module interconnection,
multiaspect modeling, inheritance,
textual-numerical attributes.
Metamodeling:
. eg, the metamodel of a fsa is a subclass of graph:
the edges are state transitions
and nodes are states .
modeling:
the model of a fsa
would then be a particular graph .
The one predefined language in this scheme
— the metamodeling language— expresses metamodels:
domain modeling languages .
. and is itself expressed in by a meta-metamodeling lang;
The MIC framework consistently applies
a meta-level architecture:
a layer is always described in terms of
the next higher layer in the hierarchy.
finding the fundamentals like math does
but in an elegant unified local-friendly language . ]
-- . the article was seen here first: softwaretechnews.thedacs.com,
and authored by metacase.com
todo:
how completely can adda merge with this?
get more .edu data about what this is .
. weed out dsl's:
Domain-Specific Languages: An Annotated Bibliography
. the key to productivity is full code generation;
that leaves you with what the modeling lang' should be;
well, starting from scratch then,
being dom'specific helps;
but you can go quite far with a general-purpose lang'
that offers user-defined control structures .
Labels:
adda,
dsm,
frameworks,
literate prog'ing,
relig,
safe pointers,
security,
sw.eng
2011-02-28
modulus vs remainder
2.7, 2.16: Using the mod() function with negative numbers
"modulo" as a relation:
[pointing in the same direction on a clock]
any two numbers a and b are congruent modulo m
if (a - b) is a multiple of m.
. math's idea of "integer division":
x . . . . : 2.7, -2.7
floor(x) .: 2.0, -3.0
ceiling(x): 3.0, -2.0 .
. for both mod (modulus) and rem (remainder),
they are related to div by:
A = ( A DIV B ) * B + A % B
where % is either { rem, mod };
. {mod, rem} are similar in that
they are both consistent with a div function;
but mod's div truncates towards -∞ (negative infinity);
whereas, rem's div truncates towards zero .
. mod(-n, d) -- vs rem -- is the complement
of mod(n, d); eg,
MOD(-340,60)= 20
MOD(340,60)= 40
(40 and 20 are complementary modulo 60;
ie, 40+20 = 60).
. truncating toward -∞ (negative infinity)
means that if n (the numerator) is negative;
then the usual integer div needs to be decremented:
div = int(n/d)-1
-- so that the truncation is consistent by
always reducing the value instead of
changing it willy-nilly towards nil
(that'd be adding value when truncating negatives
while subtracting value when truncating positives).
Ada's "mod" (modulus) and "rem" (remainder):
. notice that while Ada supports both {mod, rem}
it has only rem-consistent div (truncate toward zero)
ie, observing the identity (-A)/B = -(A/B) = A/(-B)
for A,B in positives .
by contrast, Python truncates toward -infinity .
. here is Python's mod-consistent div ( % means mod )
. 123 / 10 = 12, 123 % 10 = 3
-123 / 10 = -13, -123 % 10 = 7
. 123 /-10 = -13, 123 % -10 = -7
-123 / -10 = 12, -123 % -10 = -3
translation from ada to c:
. ada's {rem, mod} is defined for (n,d) in Z
(integers, numerator and denominator can be negatives);
let c`% = abs(n) % abs(d):
-- (%) is c's symbol for remainder function --
then depending on the original signs of n,d,
use the following table to know whether to
{complement, negate} c`% .
-- complement (~) means abs(modulus) - x;
so for modulus = 5, the complement
of 1..4
is 4..1, respectively .
for rem:
. (n rem d)`sign = n`sign
details:
. when n,d are both positive,
or only d(modulus) is negative:
eg, 1...4 rem -5 = 1..4
or 1...4 rem 5 = 1..4
--> c`% .
. when n,d are both negative,
or only n is negative:
eg, -1...-4 rem -5 = -1 .. -4;
or -1...-4 rem 5 = -1..-4
--> -c`% .
for mod:
. (n mod d)`sign = d`sign;
if only n or only d is negative,
then complement .
details:
. when n,d are both positive:
eg, 1...4 mod 5 = 1..4
--> c`% .
. when n,d are both negative:
eg, -1...-4 mod -5 = -1 .. -4
--> -c`% .
. when only d(modulus) is negative:
eg, 1...4 mod -5 = -4..-1
--> -~c`% .
. when only n is negative:
eg, -1...-4 mod 5 = 4..1
--> ~c`% .
"modulo" as a relation:
[pointing in the same direction on a clock]
any two numbers a and b are congruent modulo m
if (a - b) is a multiple of m.
. math's idea of "integer division":
x . . . . : 2.7, -2.7
floor(x) .: 2.0, -3.0
ceiling(x): 3.0, -2.0 .
. for both mod (modulus) and rem (remainder),
they are related to div by:
A = ( A DIV B ) * B + A % B
where % is either { rem, mod };
. {mod, rem} are similar in that
they are both consistent with a div function;
but mod's div truncates towards -∞ (negative infinity);
whereas, rem's div truncates towards zero .
. mod(-n, d) -- vs rem -- is the complement
of mod(n, d); eg,
MOD(-340,60)= 20
MOD(340,60)= 40
(40 and 20 are complementary modulo 60;
ie, 40+20 = 60).
. truncating toward -∞ (negative infinity)
means that if n (the numerator) is negative;
then the usual integer div needs to be decremented:
div = int(n/d)-1
-- so that the truncation is consistent by
always reducing the value instead of
changing it willy-nilly towards nil
(that'd be adding value when truncating negatives
while subtracting value when truncating positives).
Ada's "mod" (modulus) and "rem" (remainder):
. notice that while Ada supports both {mod, rem}
it has only rem-consistent div (truncate toward zero)
ie, observing the identity (-A)/B = -(A/B) = A/(-B)
for A,B in positives .
by contrast, Python truncates toward -infinity .
. here is Python's mod-consistent div ( % means mod )
. 123 / 10 = 12, 123 % 10 = 3
-123 / 10 = -13, -123 % 10 = 7
. 123 /-10 = -13, 123 % -10 = -7
-123 / -10 = 12, -123 % -10 = -3
translation from ada to c:
. ada's {rem, mod} is defined for (n,d) in Z
(integers, numerator and denominator can be negatives);
let c`% = abs(n) % abs(d):
-- (%) is c's symbol for remainder function --
then depending on the original signs of n,d,
use the following table to know whether to
{complement, negate} c`% .
-- complement (~) means abs(modulus) - x;
so for modulus = 5, the complement
of 1..4
is 4..1, respectively .
for rem:
. (n rem d)`sign = n`sign
details:
. when n,d are both positive,
or only d(modulus) is negative:
eg, 1...4 rem -5 = 1..4
or 1...4 rem 5 = 1..4
--> c`% .
. when n,d are both negative,
or only n is negative:
eg, -1...-4 rem -5 = -1 .. -4;
or -1...-4 rem 5 = -1..-4
--> -c`% .
for mod:
. (n mod d)`sign = d`sign;
if only n or only d is negative,
then complement .
details:
. when n,d are both positive:
eg, 1...4 mod 5 = 1..4
--> c`% .
. when n,d are both negative:
eg, -1...-4 mod -5 = -1 .. -4
--> -c`% .
. when only d(modulus) is negative:
eg, 1...4 mod -5 = -4..-1
--> -~c`% .
. when only n is negative:
eg, -1...-4 mod 5 = 4..1
--> ~c`% .
self as used by interfaces and anonymous algorithms
2.28: adda/lexeme/self/for anon'algor's and interfaces:
. the word"self is useful in 2 contexts:
# anonymous algorithm:
it means the current algorithm,
# type`interface:
it means a current instance of that type;
eg, t.type: ( self!: defines a postix operator).
. if there is an algorithm in the header
(eg, to declare algorithms that won't change
for some reason...)
then the usual scope rules prevail .
. the word"self is useful in 2 contexts:
# anonymous algorithm:
it means the current algorithm,
# type`interface:
it means a current instance of that type;
eg, t.type: ( self!: defines a postix operator).
. if there is an algorithm in the header
(eg, to declare algorithms that won't change
for some reason...)
then the usual scope rules prevail .
Labels:
1st-class functions,
adda,
interface,
lexeme,
oop
literals with type-defined syntax
2.28: adda/dstr/literals with type-defined syntax:
. one way to allow custom syntax
-- elegantly, without a bolt-on --
is to say that types can define
their own literal reader;
ie, a mini' type-specific compiler .
. this allows the grammar of literals to be
something other than a composite of native types,
defined instead as whatever is accepted
by the type's reader .
. during the adda.compiler's first pass,
it sorts out what's adda code
from what is either a string literal,
or a type-specific literal
having a reader-defined grammar .
. in subsequent passes,
it then uses the appropriate reader
to complete the translation of literals .
. a custom reader is not a security threat;
because while it is returning adda binary code,
that code itself is not runnable;
it must still be translated by trusted app's .
. if a type defines more than one reader,
then not mentioning a reader simply calls the default .
it can also be explicit in the usual way:
eg, .t`yet-another-reader
is a reader belonging to type t .
. the pattern: x.anytype = "(...)
results in calling anytype's default reader
-- just as with: x.string = "(string's literal);
( notice .string's default reader
doesn't have to be trivial;
in c.lang, the reader treats "(\)
as an escape character;
eg, \n -> newline, \t -> tab, ... ).
. to help adda readily identify
all the type-defined syntax readers,
they should all return the same special type,
say, .addb (adda binary),
so then in type t's interface,
any functions of type .addb
will be registered as readers for type t;
eg,
( read(x.$).addb
, another-style(x.$).addb, ...)
. a quote lexeme -- '{}, '[], '() --
means do a read (translate text to adda code)
but don't eval,
whereas, a double-quote means don't even read:
it is to be considered { .string, .$ };
so, in the case of readers,
their parameter must be a double-quoted enclosure,
or some expression that returns .string;
otherwise, it's eval'd as adda code
before being given to the reader
and then it might not even be the expected .string type .
. places where literals are encountered:
# static typing:
. the var's are declared to have a particular type;
here the type is obvious;
so the type qualifier is not needed;
eg,
x.anytype`= "(this is greek to adda)
-- that invokes .anytype's default reader;
x.string`= c-style"(string's literal\n)
-- .string's c-style reader is invoked .
# dynamic typing:
-- the type is discovered at run-time --
. adda can't find a reader at compile time
unless the reader's type is specified:
eg,
say .tall can point to all types:
xc.tall`= .string`c-style"(featuring escapes\n) .
-- now xc can point at a .string at compile`time .
. if an undeclared function is given:
eg,
g.tall`= f "(something like x );
then the work is left to the run-time exec:
it sees if the current object assigned to g
does have a type that includes
the function type: f(x.$).*
(where * can be any type);
if so, then g gets whatever type obj'
that f returns .
. string literals can have the same problem as comments:
it's easy to lose the boundaries of multi-line constructs;
and, when that happens,
the code can act strangely because
the compiler thought half the code
was a comment or string;
conversely,
if the comment or string accidently contains
the string delimiter,
some of the comment or string will be
compiled as if were code;
and if that succeeds,
the results will certainly be unintended!
. to assist the human reader,
there could be a redundant enclosure syntax:
if a string can't fit on one line,
the enclosure boundaries should be
on their own separate lines;
"(
example with
2 lines .
);
. if the text includes quote enclosures on their own line,
then the text could go in its own file:
x`= "( [!]myliteral.txt )
-- when {adda, adde} sees [ ! ] as one word,
then what follows is a command for generating text .
. a .txt file would be taken as literal text;
whereas an .adda file would be eval'd to an object
that would then be printed if not alread .string .
. one way to allow custom syntax
-- elegantly, without a bolt-on --
is to say that types can define
their own literal reader;
ie, a mini' type-specific compiler .
. this allows the grammar of literals to be
something other than a composite of native types,
defined instead as whatever is accepted
by the type's reader .
. during the adda.compiler's first pass,
it sorts out what's adda code
from what is either a string literal,
or a type-specific literal
having a reader-defined grammar .
. in subsequent passes,
it then uses the appropriate reader
to complete the translation of literals .
. a custom reader is not a security threat;
because while it is returning adda binary code,
that code itself is not runnable;
it must still be translated by trusted app's .
. if a type defines more than one reader,
then not mentioning a reader simply calls the default .
it can also be explicit in the usual way:
eg, .t`yet-another-reader
is a reader belonging to type t .
. the pattern: x.anytype = "(...)
results in calling anytype's default reader
-- just as with: x.string = "(string's literal);
( notice .string's default reader
doesn't have to be trivial;
in c.lang, the reader treats "(\)
as an escape character;
eg, \n -> newline, \t -> tab, ... ).
. to help adda readily identify
all the type-defined syntax readers,
they should all return the same special type,
say, .addb (adda binary),
so then in type t's interface,
any functions of type .addb
will be registered as readers for type t;
eg,
( read(x.$).addb
, another-style(x.$).addb, ...)
. a quote lexeme -- '{}, '[], '() --
means do a read (translate text to adda code)
but don't eval,
whereas, a double-quote means don't even read:
it is to be considered { .string, .$ };
so, in the case of readers,
their parameter must be a double-quoted enclosure,
or some expression that returns .string;
otherwise, it's eval'd as adda code
before being given to the reader
and then it might not even be the expected .string type .
. places where literals are encountered:
# static typing:
. the var's are declared to have a particular type;
here the type is obvious;
so the type qualifier is not needed;
eg,
x.anytype`= "(this is greek to adda)
-- that invokes .anytype's default reader;
x.string`= c-style"(string's literal\n)
-- .string's c-style reader is invoked .
# dynamic typing:
-- the type is discovered at run-time --
. adda can't find a reader at compile time
unless the reader's type is specified:
eg,
say .tall can point to all types:
xc.tall`= .string`c-style"(featuring escapes\n) .
-- now xc can point at a .string at compile`time .
. if an undeclared function is given:
eg,
g.tall`= f "(something like x );
then the work is left to the run-time exec:
it sees if the current object assigned to g
does have a type that includes
the function type: f(x.$).*
(where * can be any type);
if so, then g gets whatever type obj'
that f returns .
. string literals can have the same problem as comments:
it's easy to lose the boundaries of multi-line constructs;
and, when that happens,
the code can act strangely because
the compiler thought half the code
was a comment or string;
conversely,
if the comment or string accidently contains
the string delimiter,
some of the comment or string will be
compiled as if were code;
and if that succeeds,
the results will certainly be unintended!
. to assist the human reader,
there could be a redundant enclosure syntax:
if a string can't fit on one line,
the enclosure boundaries should be
on their own separate lines;
"(
example with
2 lines .
);
. if the text includes quote enclosures on their own line,
then the text could go in its own file:
x`= "( [!]myliteral.txt )
-- when {adda, adde} sees [ ! ] as one word,
then what follows is a command for generating text .
. a .txt file would be taken as literal text;
whereas an .adda file would be eval'd to an object
that would then be printed if not alread .string .
unary operators not always taking precedence over binary
2.7: news.adda/math/unary not always taking precedence:
. negation has the same precedence as
multiplication and division;
because, negation means mult by -1.
So -a^b should be -1*a^b = -(a^b).
details:
. programmers were accustomed to the C language,
in which unary operators such as negation
have higher precedence than any binary operator;
(and there was no exponent operator in C
to cause them to think twice about the matter).
so, when programmers use an exponent operator,
they may have wished to remain consistent with C;
however, for centuries,
the polynomial -x^2
has meant -1*x^2 = -(x^2)
not (-x)^2 = x^2 .
. look at the HP48G User Guide/order of operations:
priority#1:
Prefix functions (such as sin, ln, ...)
and Postfix functions (such as ! (factorial)).
--[. many could say negation is a prefix -();
2.16: nevertheless,
notice the way math has superscripted powers
(rather than using an operator);
as if it was an extension of the symbol's name
like the way subscripts actually are,
and thus intuitively having higher precedence
than any operation applied to the name .]
priority#2: Power (^) and square root.
priority#3: Negation (-), multiplication, and division.
--[. here is the 2nd place -() fits;
but, only because of its equvalence to -1*();
many think it's obvious that the negative
is part of the number's value .]
priority#4: Addition and subtraction.
. clarity should take precedence over correctness;
so, the system needs to ask new users
-- at least those who use the form (-x^n):
or allowing copies to text
always write it unambiguously { -(2^2), (-2)^2 }.
. negation has the same precedence as
multiplication and division;
because, negation means mult by -1.
So -a^b should be -1*a^b = -(a^b).
details:
. programmers were accustomed to the C language,
in which unary operators such as negation
have higher precedence than any binary operator;
(and there was no exponent operator in C
to cause them to think twice about the matter).
so, when programmers use an exponent operator,
they may have wished to remain consistent with C;
however, for centuries,
the polynomial -x^2
has meant -1*x^2 = -(x^2)
not (-x)^2 = x^2 .
. look at the HP48G User Guide/order of operations:
priority#1:
Prefix functions (such as sin, ln, ...)
and Postfix functions (such as ! (factorial)).
--[. many could say negation is a prefix -();
2.16: nevertheless,
notice the way math has superscripted powers
(rather than using an operator);
as if it was an extension of the symbol's name
like the way subscripts actually are,
and thus intuitively having higher precedence
than any operation applied to the name .]
priority#2: Power (^) and square root.
priority#3: Negation (-), multiplication, and division.
--[. here is the 2nd place -() fits;
but, only because of its equvalence to -1*();
many think it's obvious that the negative
is part of the number's value .]
priority#4: Addition and subtraction.
. clarity should take precedence over correctness;
so, the system needs to ask new users
-- at least those who use the form (-x^n):
"( how would you eval -2^2 ?. furthermore, when exporting adda`binary,
{ 4, -4 } ??
. -1*2^2 is definitely = -1(2^2) = -4 .
whereas (-2)^2 = (-2)(-2) = 4 . )
or allowing copies to text
always write it unambiguously { -(2^2), (-2)^2 }.
Labels:
ABI,
adda,
lexeme,
math,
precedence,
superscript
vertical bar for divisions not xor
2.7, 2.15: adda/vertical bar operator uses:
. the vertical bar operator has several uses
that are quite similar across most fields:
number theory:
. n|m is a truth function: does m divide n evenly?
because of that,
I wondered if it could double as the div operator;
ie, (int / int) -> Q (float or rational);
whereas (int | int) -> Z {truncate, floor, ceiling, ...}
. if you consider context, there is indeed
precidence for (n|m) as a div operator:
in number theory, (n|m) assumes
the result is being passed to a truth variable .
. this is also how (=) doubles as {equals, becomes}
in the basic.lang (eg, if a=b then a=c);
case depending on type:
# number? integer quotient;
# truth? mod = 0 .
. notice though, that the question of divisibility
is actually depending on the mod operation ...;
set theory:
{ f(x) | x`range } -- set generators
f(x) | (x in range) -- definite integrals .
-- like number theory, it concerns division:
the set is infinite until divided by
the finite range of its control variable .
linguistics:
. (a|b|c) means pick exactly one,
reminding me of unique existence;
however, in systems programming
there is often a need to apply both div's
and bit-wise xor's to the same ints;
eg, n xor (n div 31);
so, I'm wondering if I can find
something besides (|) for xor,
since it already fits nicely with div .
. math's existence operator(∃) adds a bang(!)
to express a unique existence:
eg, ( for some! x: p(x,y) )
would mean
( for exactly one x: p(x,y) );
[2.28:
. notice how math uses separate operators
whenever there is quantification
or control var's involved;
even though it could be more elegant
if it reused set generators:
eg, +(i.int|i = 1...n)
is a summation over 1..n;
math would prefer to present this as:
n
∑ (i)
i = 1 .
. likewise, math's ∃x(p(x)) can also be
expressed as
or( p(x)| x in universe );
\/ is math's operator for logical-or;
therefore,
in the pursuit of minimal language,]
a good symbol for unique existence
could be \! .
. xor is used often in computingand is like unique existence
but only for the special pair-wise case:
. the composition of xor's for reducing
a list larger than a pair
is not generally equivalent to an (\!);
because, recursively, an xor's return of false
may indicate either {many, none};
while a return of true indicates uniqueness;
so then here is a counter example
(existence but non-unique):
whereas this was an example of many,
which should have registered as false
if testing for unique existence .
. math`s symbol for xor is a circled plus
reminding us it functions as
clock addition modulo 2 .
. if restricting the arg of (\!) to pairs
a computer's xor operation can implement
unique existence .
. the vertical bar operator has several uses
that are quite similar across most fields:
number theory:
. n|m is a truth function: does m divide n evenly?
because of that,
I wondered if it could double as the div operator;
ie, (int / int) -> Q (float or rational);
whereas (int | int) -> Z {truncate, floor, ceiling, ...}
. if you consider context, there is indeed
precidence for (n|m) as a div operator:
in number theory, (n|m) assumes
the result is being passed to a truth variable .
. this is also how (=) doubles as {equals, becomes}
in the basic.lang (eg, if a=b then a=c);
case depending on type:
# number? integer quotient;
# truth? mod = 0 .
. notice though, that the question of divisibility
is actually depending on the mod operation ...;
set theory:
{ f(x) | x`range } -- set generators
f(x) | (x in range) -- definite integrals .
-- like number theory, it concerns division:
the set is infinite until divided by
the finite range of its control variable .
linguistics:
. (a|b|c) means pick exactly one,
reminding me of unique existence;
however, in systems programming
there is often a need to apply both div's
and bit-wise xor's to the same ints;
eg, n xor (n div 31);
so, I'm wondering if I can find
something besides (|) for xor,
since it already fits nicely with div .
. math's existence operator(∃) adds a bang(!)
to express a unique existence:
eg, ( for some! x: p(x,y) )
would mean
( for exactly one x: p(x,y) );
[2.28:
. notice how math uses separate operators
whenever there is quantification
or control var's involved;
even though it could be more elegant
if it reused set generators:
eg, +(i.int|i = 1...n)
is a summation over 1..n;
math would prefer to present this as:
n
∑ (i)
i = 1 .
. likewise, math's ∃x(p(x)) can also be
expressed as
or( p(x)| x in universe );
\/ is math's operator for logical-or;
therefore,
in the pursuit of minimal language,]
a good symbol for unique existence
could be \! .
. xor is used often in computingand is like unique existence
but only for the special pair-wise case:
. the composition of xor's for reducing
a list larger than a pair
is not generally equivalent to an (\!);
because, recursively, an xor's return of false
may indicate either {many, none};
while a return of true indicates uniqueness;
so then here is a counter example
(existence but non-unique):
(true xor true) xor (true xor false)but true was supposed to mean unique;
(many) xor (unique) =
(false) xor (true) = true
whereas this was an example of many,
which should have registered as false
if testing for unique existence .
. math`s symbol for xor is a circled plus
reminding us it functions as
clock addition modulo 2 .
. if restricting the arg of (\!) to pairs
a computer's xor operation can implement
unique existence .
menucode
2.4: adda/dstr/menucode:
. menucode is a variation of the index-style pointer
. it's a finite enumeration that is then mapped to
pointers or indexes .
2.14:
. what pointers and indexes have in common is
being addresses of a memory implementation .
. this is in contrast to opcodes and menucodes
which are specifying what you want to address
rather than where its address is .
. menucode is a variation of the index-style pointer
. it's a finite enumeration that is then mapped to
pointers or indexes .
2.14:
. what pointers and indexes have in common is
being addresses of a memory implementation .
. this is in contrast to opcodes and menucodes
which are specifying what you want to address
rather than where its address is .
Labels:
adda,
dstr,
safe pointers,
terminology
clarity in a unicode world
2.2: adda/clarity in a unicode world:
oreilly commenters mention rust:
. Rust is Mozilla's new lower-level language;
it has a policy of ASCII-only lexemes.
. all platforms have Unicode libraries,
so why go ASCII-only ? [2.9:
At the moment it’s just a matter of
keeping the lexer simple
(no character-class tables to consult)
as well as making it accessable to all unix tools .]
. I first conjectured ASCII-only was for security:
it's for the same reason that
website names should be ascii;
if you have 2 names that look the same,
but one uses european letters,
then people could get them confused .
. the question for a lang then is
how can the compiler give writers freedom
and still help readers stay unconfused?
# highlighting:
. whenever non-ascii could be confused with ascii,
it would be in a contrasting font or style .
# substitution:
. the editor makes it easy to
change variable names:
after parsing, a name is identified as a var';
and, the var links to its scope,
so, after a user has changed the var's name,
the entire text for that scope is re-displayed
so that all instances of the var's name
reflect the user's preference .
integrate with translations:
. like chrome.browser is integrated with
google-translate,
have the editor translate any foreign characters
to the user's {alphabet, vocabulary} .
oreilly commenters mention rust:
. Rust is Mozilla's new lower-level language;
it has a policy of ASCII-only lexemes.
. all platforms have Unicode libraries,
so why go ASCII-only ? [2.9:
At the moment it’s just a matter of
keeping the lexer simple
(no character-class tables to consult)
as well as making it accessable to all unix tools .]
. I first conjectured ASCII-only was for security:
it's for the same reason that
website names should be ascii;
if you have 2 names that look the same,
but one uses european letters,
then people could get them confused .
. the question for a lang then is
how can the compiler give writers freedom
and still help readers stay unconfused?
# highlighting:
. whenever non-ascii could be confused with ascii,
it would be in a contrasting font or style .
# substitution:
. the editor makes it easy to
change variable names:
after parsing, a name is identified as a var';
and, the var links to its scope,
so, after a user has changed the var's name,
the entire text for that scope is re-displayed
so that all instances of the var's name
reflect the user's preference .
integrate with translations:
. like chrome.browser is integrated with
google-translate,
have the editor translate any foreign characters
to the user's {alphabet, vocabulary} .
2011-01-31
graphics-intensive social web
1.16: addx/architecture/graphic intensive social web:
. one way to make remote games is like mvc:
the objects are very compactly encoded at main;
there are no graphics transmitted;
instead,
the matrix describes typical shapes and positions
then updates are sent as difference matrices
which are added to the local absolute matrices,
then the local graphics engine fleshes out these codes,
first into user's preferred forms and themes,
eg, the 3-d polygon compositions,
then ray tracing from these
into the screen graphics .
. it still requires a fast large local machine,
but the networking is not the bottleneck .
. one way to make remote games is like mvc:
the objects are very compactly encoded at main;
there are no graphics transmitted;
instead,
the matrix describes typical shapes and positions
then updates are sent as difference matrices
which are added to the local absolute matrices,
then the local graphics engine fleshes out these codes,
first into user's preferred forms and themes,
eg, the 3-d polygon compositions,
then ray tracing from these
into the screen graphics .
. it still requires a fast large local machine,
but the networking is not the bottleneck .
Labels:
addx,
architecture,
gui
concurrent search and replace
1.16: adde/search and replace:
. a concurrent search and replace (s&r)
takes a tab-tab-enter list of targets and replacements,
this way user doesn't have to worry about
ordering multiple s&r's in the case where
one replacement might contain the target of another
ie, you want only original content to be replaced,
not anything put there by the
current list of replacements .
. this can also apply session-wide:
the s&r dialog would show all your previous s&r's
and show what's been morph'd during this session .
. there's 3 classes of text to apply changes to:
{ original, s&r-morph'd, new text }.
. what if a list of searches is given
and one target is a substring of the other?
warn user you'll be doing search of largest first,
[don't warn about this again] is default true ...
1.26: eg, if I can have the s&r set:
phil -> philosophy
philip -> philosopher;
and then what it should do is check for both targets
and case:
# no match? move on;
# only one match? apply map;
# both match? apply superstring's map .
. a concurrent search and replace (s&r)
takes a tab-tab-enter list of targets and replacements,
this way user doesn't have to worry about
ordering multiple s&r's in the case where
one replacement might contain the target of another
ie, you want only original content to be replaced,
not anything put there by the
current list of replacements .
. this can also apply session-wide:
the s&r dialog would show all your previous s&r's
and show what's been morph'd during this session .
. there's 3 classes of text to apply changes to:
{ original, s&r-morph'd, new text }.
. what if a list of searches is given
and one target is a substring of the other?
warn user you'll be doing search of largest first,
[don't warn about this again] is default true ...
1.26: eg, if I can have the s&r set:
phil -> philosophy
philip -> philosopher;
and then what it should do is check for both targets
and case:
# no match? move on;
# only one match? apply map;
# both match? apply superstring's map .
first-class gui
1.10: adde/first-class dialogs:
. in addition to being able to see the
entirety of any path of a wizard
without having to fill it out,
you can treat dialogs like files,
and do a [save as] on partially filled dialogs,
then when given a dialog,
you can use [open file] to complete the dialog .
1.17: adde/gui/what's going on?!:
. what seems to be a copy ctrl-c of the firefox address bar,
is not taking the first time,
go back and switch windows, and ctrl-c again and it works?
it needs a confirmation that this happened
like a tiny brief popup of the time .
1.20: adde/gui/receptivity:
. ubuntu.gnome.firefox surprises me with
the way it shows the cursor:
. if you lower the cursor into the firefox address box,
the entire cursor can be in the box (including the tip)
and it still doesn't turn into
the I-bar that indicates insertion;
I am intuitively used to putting the cursor near the bar,
and without noticing it turn into the I-bar
expecting the mouse-down to put me into
editing the address bar .
. ubuntu.gnome is too finicky !
it should work like this:
if you do a mouse-down in a place that doesn't respond,
it should be finding the closest thing you likely meant;
if there is more than one thing nearby,
it should use a list of nearby things,
or a magnified window of the graphics
showing where usable things are
vs where your cursor is .
1.31: adde/pervasive shortcuts:
. all the radio buttons and checkboxes
should be large eno to contain keys
to tell you how to mark them by keyboard .
. in addition to being able to see the
entirety of any path of a wizard
without having to fill it out,
you can treat dialogs like files,
and do a [save as] on partially filled dialogs,
then when given a dialog,
you can use [open file] to complete the dialog .
1.17: adde/gui/what's going on?!:
. what seems to be a copy ctrl-c of the firefox address bar,
is not taking the first time,
go back and switch windows, and ctrl-c again and it works?
it needs a confirmation that this happened
like a tiny brief popup of the time .
1.20: adde/gui/receptivity:
. ubuntu.gnome.firefox surprises me with
the way it shows the cursor:
. if you lower the cursor into the firefox address box,
the entire cursor can be in the box (including the tip)
and it still doesn't turn into
the I-bar that indicates insertion;
I am intuitively used to putting the cursor near the bar,
and without noticing it turn into the I-bar
expecting the mouse-down to put me into
editing the address bar .
. ubuntu.gnome is too finicky !
it should work like this:
if you do a mouse-down in a place that doesn't respond,
it should be finding the closest thing you likely meant;
if there is more than one thing nearby,
it should use a list of nearby things,
or a magnified window of the graphics
showing where usable things are
vs where your cursor is .
1.31: adde/pervasive shortcuts:
. all the radio buttons and checkboxes
should be large eno to contain keys
to tell you how to mark them by keyboard .
Labels:
adde,
dialogs,
gui,
keyboard shortcuts
byte-sized pointers
1.18: adda/dstr/byte-sized pointers:
. keep pointers small by seeing large lists
as subtrees;
one of the node types of a tree is
"(this subtree root declares a new subheap:
it includes access to a 256-size array of tree node).
. how does that scale? it does because
root of huge subtree had its own subheap
where all terminal nodes were tagged as
(this is a sys'ptr [32bit c pointer]
-- not a pair of byte-sized tree ptrs [byte'ptr])
[1.31:
. as the tree progresses downward with fanout,
it eventually consumes 256 nodes;
any tree-building further down
must be done from a new-subheap node`type
(ie, a node whose purpose is to declare that
the following subtree is based in a new subheap).
. lets say that a tree uses
2 subheaps worth of nodes;
then if the tree is balanced,
it can be built with only 2 new-subheap nodes
by putting the left and right subtrees
each in their own subheap;
if the tree is not balanced,
then space efficiency requires that subheaps be shareable,
so that many smaller subtrees can be
impl'd on the same subheap .
. to make best use of space,
the use of new-subheap node`types
must be minimized because they are overhead .]
. when having a ptr to subtree,
it needs a record:
sys`ptr to the subheap,
byte'ptr to where in the subheap subtree is rooted .
. when building trees from text, [1.31:
or when trees can be modified? ..]
then we need speed more than mem'
whereas figuring out how to pack for byte-ptr's
would be very time-consuming;
so, then these sort of trees should be word-sized .
. both sizes are distinguished from sys'pointers
with the term "(local ptr):
whereas a system pointer is logically a machine address
(practically an index into a process module),
a local ptr is always an index into the current subheap .
1.31:
. our tree node has less than 16 variants,
so the tag can fit in 4bits (a half-byte, nibble,
-- addressing a byte to extract the {hi,lo} 4bits );
the node's data will be sizes larger than a nibble,
and the tag should be at the beginning
to tell us what the rest of the node looks like;
so, in order to accommodate mem'allignment requirements,
without wasteful padding after the tag,
the subheap will have 2 forks
so that tags and data can each be
in their own arrays .
. a subheap supporting byte-ptr's
can hold only 256 nodes,
in turn needing a 128-byte chunk for the 256 * 4bit tags .
. these nodes are word sized:
#branch: (tag, left.byte-ptr, right.byte-ptr);
#leaf: (tag, symbol.word-ptr).
. subheaps are composed of chunks;
so, if a subheap is not enirely used,
it's not entirely alloc'd either .
. both byte-ptr and word-ptr subheaps
can use the same size chunks, 128 bytes,
to match the minimum chunk needed for tags .
. therefore 256*2byte data nodes = 128*2*2 = 4 chunks .
. if less than half of nodes are used,
then it can save on 2 chunks of 128 bytes .
. finally, a byte-ptr subheap needs to be
an array of 5 sys'pointers for access to the
1 tag chunk + 4 data chunks,
plus
whatever else is needed for variant tagging,
or part of an efficiency hack .
. if a large structure has a known minimum at init' time,
then it can be given a superchunk,
which is some arbitrary multiple of contiguous chunks .
. keep pointers small by seeing large lists
as subtrees;
one of the node types of a tree is
"(this subtree root declares a new subheap:
it includes access to a 256-size array of tree node).
. how does that scale? it does because
root of huge subtree had its own subheap
where all terminal nodes were tagged as
(this is a sys'ptr [32bit c pointer]
-- not a pair of byte-sized tree ptrs [byte'ptr])
[1.31:
. as the tree progresses downward with fanout,
it eventually consumes 256 nodes;
any tree-building further down
must be done from a new-subheap node`type
(ie, a node whose purpose is to declare that
the following subtree is based in a new subheap).
. lets say that a tree uses
2 subheaps worth of nodes;
then if the tree is balanced,
it can be built with only 2 new-subheap nodes
by putting the left and right subtrees
each in their own subheap;
if the tree is not balanced,
then space efficiency requires that subheaps be shareable,
so that many smaller subtrees can be
impl'd on the same subheap .
. to make best use of space,
the use of new-subheap node`types
must be minimized because they are overhead .]
. when having a ptr to subtree,
it needs a record:
sys`ptr to the subheap,
byte'ptr to where in the subheap subtree is rooted .
. when building trees from text, [1.31:
or when trees can be modified? ..]
then we need speed more than mem'
whereas figuring out how to pack for byte-ptr's
would be very time-consuming;
so, then these sort of trees should be word-sized .
. both sizes are distinguished from sys'pointers
with the term "(local ptr):
whereas a system pointer is logically a machine address
(practically an index into a process module),
a local ptr is always an index into the current subheap .
1.31:
. our tree node has less than 16 variants,
so the tag can fit in 4bits (a half-byte, nibble,
-- addressing a byte to extract the {hi,lo} 4bits );
the node's data will be sizes larger than a nibble,
and the tag should be at the beginning
to tell us what the rest of the node looks like;
so, in order to accommodate mem'allignment requirements,
without wasteful padding after the tag,
the subheap will have 2 forks
so that tags and data can each be
in their own arrays .
. a subheap supporting byte-ptr's
can hold only 256 nodes,
in turn needing a 128-byte chunk for the 256 * 4bit tags .
. these nodes are word sized:
#branch: (tag, left.byte-ptr, right.byte-ptr);
#leaf: (tag, symbol.word-ptr).
. subheaps are composed of chunks;
so, if a subheap is not enirely used,
it's not entirely alloc'd either .
. both byte-ptr and word-ptr subheaps
can use the same size chunks, 128 bytes,
to match the minimum chunk needed for tags .
. therefore 256*2byte data nodes = 128*2*2 = 4 chunks .
. if less than half of nodes are used,
then it can save on 2 chunks of 128 bytes .
. finally, a byte-ptr subheap needs to be
an array of 5 sys'pointers for access to the
1 tag chunk + 4 data chunks,
plus
whatever else is needed for variant tagging,
or part of an efficiency hack .
. if a large structure has a known minimum at init' time,
then it can be given a superchunk,
which is some arbitrary multiple of contiguous chunks .
2010-12-31
survey of programming architectures
11.15: web.adda/oop/architectures:
the categories of inheritance:
# type clustering (inclusion polymorphism):
. numbers are the classic type cluster;
that type's major subtypes have overlapping interfaces;
and they need a supertype to coordinate biop's
(binary operations; a function with 2 arg's;
eg, addition's signature is: +:NxN->N )
whenever the param's have unmatched subtypes
(eg, RxC->C, ZxN->Z, /:NxN->Q, ...).
type cluster/supervision models:
#coordinated:
. the set of polymorphic subtypes is fixed,
and the supertype knows how to convert between them;
because,
it knows the data formats of all its subtypes .
# translated:
. the supertype provides an all-inclusive
universal data format;
eg, numbers -> complex .
. all subtypes convert between that format
and their own .
type cluster/subtypes must include range constraints:
. range constraints are essential for efficiency
as well as stronger static typing;
because, range limits are what allow
direct use of native numeric types .
. typical native types include
{N,Z,R}{8,16,32,64,128} .
# type classing (Subtype polymorphism):
. declaring a type is a member of a class,
and is compatable with that class
by inheriting its interface;
the new type is then usable
anywhere the inherited class is . [12.31:
. the type class is defined by its interface;
any type following that interface
is considered a member of that class .
. it's not about sharing code by extension;
it's organizing hierarchies of compatability .]
# type cluster combined with type classing:
. the subtypes of a type cluster
can be type classed; eg,
a dimensioned number could inherit from int;
and then to coordinate with the numeric supertype
it uses functionality from int.type
to deal with these messages:
{ what is your numeric subtype?
, your numeric value?
, replace your numeric value with this one
} .
. with just that interface,
any subclass of any numeric subtype
can be used in any numeric operation . [12.31:
. all self-modifying operations ( x`f)
can be translated as assignments (x`= f(x));
so then the inherited subtype
provides all the transform code .]
#type classing without clustering:
11.20:
. without type clustering;
what does type classing do then?
are biop's supported? polymorphism?
. historical reasons for inheritance:
# polymorphism
# type compatability
# reuse of work .
. you want to extend a type's
structure and functionality,
not interfere with its code base,
and still be useful everywhere your ancestors are .
. in the popular oop model,
the inherited work is reused by
adding to an inherited type's
functionality and instance var'space
(creating a polymorphism in the type).
. there's type compatability because
the obj' can handle all the ancestor's
unary and self-modifying functions;
but, popular oop approaches differ on
how biop's are handled .
. the classic, math'al oop uses clusters, [12.31:
which can handle biop's because the supertype
has limited membership to its type class
and can thus know in advance
what combinations of subtypes to expect
among a biop's pair of arg's .
. in a system without clustering's
closed class of subtypes
then there is no particular type to handle
the coordination of mixed biop arg's .
(that mix can consist of any types in
one arg's ancestors, or their descendents).]
. if subtypes can redefine a biop,
then a biop's method might be arbitrated by:
# nearest common ancestor:
the arg' set's nearest common ancestor type;
# popular:
the first arg determines the method;
# translation:
. an inheritable type has a universal format
which inheritors convert to,
in order to use the root's biop method .]
# incremental composition:
. it can be simplifying to describe a type
in terms of how it differs from other types;
this case includes anything not considered to be
type clustering or subclassing .
. revisions such as removing inherited parts
can preclude type compatability;
in such cases, compatability could be declared
with the use of a conversion map .
. incremental composition provides
module operators for building in ways
familiar to lisp users:
code can read other code, modify it,
and then use it as a module definition .
[11.20:
. with incremental composition,
any inheritance behaviors should be possible;
but the built-in inheritance should be
simple, classic type clustering and classing
as described above .
. the directions of popular oop
are not helping either readability or reuse;
esp'y unrewarding is the ability to
inherit multiple implementations
that have overlapping interfaces .]
#frameworks:
11.15:
. generic types can implement frameworks:
a type is an interface with all code supplied;
a generic type
leaves some of its interface undefined
or optionally redefinable,
with the intent that parameter instantiations
are customizing the framework;
eg,
a typical gui framework would be impl'd as
a generic task type;
so that creating an obj' of that type
initiates a thread of execution
that captures all user input
and responds to these events by
calling functions supplied by the
framework's customizing init's .]
adda/oop/value types:
11.16:
. the classic use of oop is type clustering
as is done for numerics:
it provides users of the numeric library
with an effortless, automated way
to use a variety of numeric subtypes
while also employing static typing,
and enjoying any enhanced readability or safety
that may be provided by that .
. coercions and range checks can all be
tucked under the hood,
without requiring compliance from clients .
. this automation is possible because
the designer of a type cluster's supertype
is using subtype tags to determine
each value's data format .
. the supertype module is also
the only place to coordinate
multiple param's having unmatched subtypes;
after one param' is coerced to match the other,
operations involving matched binary subtypes
are then relegated to subtype modules .
11.19: intro to value`type:
. static typing generally means
that a var's allowed values are confined to
one declared type,
and perhaps also constrained;
eg, limited to a range of values,
or a specific subtype .
. if that declared type is a type cluster,
it's values will include a type tag
for use by the supertype module,
to indicate which of its subtype modules
is responsible for that data format .
. type.tags are sometimes seen as a way to
replace Static typing with ducktyping
(where the tag is used at run-time
to check that the given value has a type
that is compatible with the requested operation).
. type clustering, in contrast to ducktyping,
is static typing with polymorphism
(statically bound to the cluster's supertype);
and there, the purpose of the type.tag
is merely to allow the supertype module
to support a variety of subtypes,
usually for the efficiency to be gained
from supporting a variety of data formats;
eg,
if huge complex numbers won't be used,
then a real.tag can indicate there is
no mem' allocated for the imaginary component;
or,
if only int's within a certain range will be used,
then the format can be that of a native int,
which is considerably faster than non-native formats .
. the value's subtype (or value`type)
is contrasted with a var's subtype
to remind us that they need not be equal
as long as they are compatable;
eg,
a var' of type"real may contain
a value of type"integer;
because they are both subtypes of number,
and the integer values are a
subset of the real values
(independent of format).
. the obj's subtype puts a limit on
the value`types it can support;
eg,
while a var' of subtype"R16 (16bit float)
can coerce any ints to float,
it raises an exception if that float
can't fit in a 16-bit storage .
. another possibly interesting distinction
between var' types and value`types
is that value`types have no concept of
operating on self; [11.19:
a unary operation over a value`type
doesn't involve any addresses,
and there is nothing being modified .
. while popular oop has a var`address
modify itself with a msg,
eg, x`f;
classic oop would say that was an
assignment stmt plus a unary operation:
x`= x`type`f(x) -- shown here fully qualified
to indicate how modularity is preserved:
the function belongs to x's type .]
. adda can also enforce typing between
unrelated types like {pure number, Meters},
but the system depends on supertype designers
to correctly handle their own subtypes .
. in addition to the distinction between
{library, application} programmers,
there is also kernel mode:
the adda run-time manages all native types
so that any code that
could be responsible for system crashes
is all in one module .
10.23: news.adda/compositional modularity:
11.14: Bracha, Lindstrom 1992`Modularity meets Inheritance
11.14:
. that compositional modularity
sounds interesting,
what's the author been up to recently?
reflective cap'based security lang's!
Bracha 2010`Modules as Objects in Newspeak:
whatever you foreigners want to do,
do it on your own box (thread, module)
and send me the neat results .
the categories of inheritance:
# type clustering (inclusion polymorphism):
. numbers are the classic type cluster;
that type's major subtypes have overlapping interfaces;
and they need a supertype to coordinate biop's
(binary operations; a function with 2 arg's;
eg, addition's signature is: +:NxN->N )
whenever the param's have unmatched subtypes
(eg, RxC->C, ZxN->Z, /:NxN->Q, ...).
type cluster/supervision models:
#coordinated:
. the set of polymorphic subtypes is fixed,
and the supertype knows how to convert between them;
because,
it knows the data formats of all its subtypes .
# translated:
. the supertype provides an all-inclusive
universal data format;
eg, numbers -> complex .
. all subtypes convert between that format
and their own .
type cluster/subtypes must include range constraints:
. range constraints are essential for efficiency
as well as stronger static typing;
because, range limits are what allow
direct use of native numeric types .
. typical native types include
{N,Z,R}{8,16,32,64,128} .
# type classing (Subtype polymorphism):
. declaring a type is a member of a class,
and is compatable with that class
by inheriting its interface;
the new type is then usable
anywhere the inherited class is . [12.31:
. the type class is defined by its interface;
any type following that interface
is considered a member of that class .
. it's not about sharing code by extension;
it's organizing hierarchies of compatability .]
# type cluster combined with type classing:
. the subtypes of a type cluster
can be type classed; eg,
a dimensioned number could inherit from int;
and then to coordinate with the numeric supertype
it uses functionality from int.type
to deal with these messages:
{ what is your numeric subtype?
, your numeric value?
, replace your numeric value with this one
} .
. with just that interface,
any subclass of any numeric subtype
can be used in any numeric operation . [12.31:
. all self-modifying operations ( x`f)
can be translated as assignments (x`= f(x));
so then the inherited subtype
provides all the transform code .]
#type classing without clustering:
11.20:
. without type clustering;
what does type classing do then?
are biop's supported? polymorphism?
. historical reasons for inheritance:
# polymorphism
# type compatability
# reuse of work .
. you want to extend a type's
structure and functionality,
not interfere with its code base,
and still be useful everywhere your ancestors are .
. in the popular oop model,
the inherited work is reused by
adding to an inherited type's
functionality and instance var'space
(creating a polymorphism in the type).
. there's type compatability because
the obj' can handle all the ancestor's
unary and self-modifying functions;
but, popular oop approaches differ on
how biop's are handled .
. the classic, math'al oop uses clusters, [12.31:
which can handle biop's because the supertype
has limited membership to its type class
and can thus know in advance
what combinations of subtypes to expect
among a biop's pair of arg's .
. in a system without clustering's
closed class of subtypes
then there is no particular type to handle
the coordination of mixed biop arg's .
(that mix can consist of any types in
one arg's ancestors, or their descendents).]
. if subtypes can redefine a biop,
then a biop's method might be arbitrated by:
# nearest common ancestor:
the arg' set's nearest common ancestor type;
# popular:
the first arg determines the method;
# translation:
. an inheritable type has a universal format
which inheritors convert to,
in order to use the root's biop method .]
# incremental composition:
. it can be simplifying to describe a type
in terms of how it differs from other types;
this case includes anything not considered to be
type clustering or subclassing .
. revisions such as removing inherited parts
can preclude type compatability;
in such cases, compatability could be declared
with the use of a conversion map .
. incremental composition provides
module operators for building in ways
familiar to lisp users:
code can read other code, modify it,
and then use it as a module definition .
[11.20:
. with incremental composition,
any inheritance behaviors should be possible;
but the built-in inheritance should be
simple, classic type clustering and classing
as described above .
. the directions of popular oop
are not helping either readability or reuse;
esp'y unrewarding is the ability to
inherit multiple implementations
that have overlapping interfaces .]
#frameworks:
11.15:
. generic types can implement frameworks:
a type is an interface with all code supplied;
a generic type
leaves some of its interface undefined
or optionally redefinable,
with the intent that parameter instantiations
are customizing the framework;
eg,
a typical gui framework would be impl'd as
a generic task type;
so that creating an obj' of that type
initiates a thread of execution
that captures all user input
and responds to these events by
calling functions supplied by the
framework's customizing init's .]
adda/oop/value types:
11.16:
. the classic use of oop is type clustering
as is done for numerics:
it provides users of the numeric library
with an effortless, automated way
to use a variety of numeric subtypes
while also employing static typing,
and enjoying any enhanced readability or safety
that may be provided by that .
. coercions and range checks can all be
tucked under the hood,
without requiring compliance from clients .
. this automation is possible because
the designer of a type cluster's supertype
is using subtype tags to determine
each value's data format .
. the supertype module is also
the only place to coordinate
multiple param's having unmatched subtypes;
after one param' is coerced to match the other,
operations involving matched binary subtypes
are then relegated to subtype modules .
11.19: intro to value`type:
. static typing generally means
that a var's allowed values are confined to
one declared type,
and perhaps also constrained;
eg, limited to a range of values,
or a specific subtype .
. if that declared type is a type cluster,
it's values will include a type tag
for use by the supertype module,
to indicate which of its subtype modules
is responsible for that data format .
. type.tags are sometimes seen as a way to
replace Static typing with ducktyping
(where the tag is used at run-time
to check that the given value has a type
that is compatible with the requested operation).
. type clustering, in contrast to ducktyping,
is static typing with polymorphism
(statically bound to the cluster's supertype);
and there, the purpose of the type.tag
is merely to allow the supertype module
to support a variety of subtypes,
usually for the efficiency to be gained
from supporting a variety of data formats;
eg,
if huge complex numbers won't be used,
then a real.tag can indicate there is
no mem' allocated for the imaginary component;
or,
if only int's within a certain range will be used,
then the format can be that of a native int,
which is considerably faster than non-native formats .
. the value's subtype (or value`type)
is contrasted with a var's subtype
to remind us that they need not be equal
as long as they are compatable;
eg,
a var' of type"real may contain
a value of type"integer;
because they are both subtypes of number,
and the integer values are a
subset of the real values
(independent of format).
. the obj's subtype puts a limit on
the value`types it can support;
eg,
while a var' of subtype"R16 (16bit float)
can coerce any ints to float,
it raises an exception if that float
can't fit in a 16-bit storage .
. another possibly interesting distinction
between var' types and value`types
is that value`types have no concept of
operating on self; [11.19:
a unary operation over a value`type
doesn't involve any addresses,
and there is nothing being modified .
. while popular oop has a var`address
modify itself with a msg,
eg, x`f;
classic oop would say that was an
assignment stmt plus a unary operation:
x`= x`type`f(x) -- shown here fully qualified
to indicate how modularity is preserved:
the function belongs to x's type .]
. adda can also enforce typing between
unrelated types like {pure number, Meters},
but the system depends on supertype designers
to correctly handle their own subtypes .
. in addition to the distinction between
{library, application} programmers,
there is also kernel mode:
the adda run-time manages all native types
so that any code that
could be responsible for system crashes
is all in one module .
10.23: news.adda/compositional modularity:
11.14: Bracha, Lindstrom 1992`Modularity meets Inheritance
We "unbundle" the roles of classes10.23: Banavar 1995`compositional modularity app framework:
by providing a suite of operators
independently controlling such effects as
combination, modification, encapsulation,
name resolution, and sharing,
all on the single notion of module.
All module operators are forms of inheritance.
Thus, inheritance not only is
not in conflict with modularity in our system,
but is its foundation.
This allows a previously unobtainable
spectrum of features
to be combined in a cohesive manner,
including multiple inheritance, mixins,
encapsulation and strong typing.
We demonstrate our approach in a language:
Jigsaw is modular in two senses:
# it manipulates modules,
# it is highly modular in its own conception,
permitting various module combinators to be
included, omitted, or newly constructed
in various realizations .
11.14:
. it provides not only decomposition and encapsulation
but also module recomposition .
. the model of compositional modularity is itself
realized as a generic, reusable software arch',
an oo-app framework" Etyma
that borrows meta module operators
from the module manipulation lang, Jigsaw
-- Bracha 1992`modularity meets inheritance .
. it efficiently builds completions;
ie, tools for compositionally modular system .
. it uses the unix toolbox approach:
each module does just one thing well,
but has sophisticated and reliable mechanisms
for massive recomposition .
. forms of composition:
#functional: returns are piped to param's;
#data-flow: data filters piped;
#conventional modules: lib api calls;
# compositional modularity:
. interfaces and module impl's
operated on to obtain new modules .
. oop inheritance is a form of recomposition;
it's a linguistic mechanism that supports
reuse via incremental programming;
ie, describing a system in terms of
how it differs from another system .
. compositional modularity evolves
traditional modules beyond oop .
. that compositional modularity
sounds interesting,
what's the author been up to recently?
reflective cap'based security lang's!
Bracha 2010`Modules as Objects in Newspeak:
. a module can exist as several instances;--. this is the equivalent of SOA:
they can be mutually recursive .
. Newspeak, a msg-based lang has no globals,
and all names are late-bound (obj' msg's).
. programming to an interface (msg's vs methods)
is central to modularity .
. it features cap'based security:
# obj's can hide internals
even from other instances of the same class;
# obj's have no access to globals
thus avoiding [ambient authority]
(being modified by external agents) .
# unlike E-lang, Newspeak supports reflection .
Newspeak handles foreign functions
by wrapping them in an alien obj,
rather than let safe code
call unsafe functions directly .
whatever you foreigners want to do,
do it on your own box (thread, module)
and send me the neat results .
Labels:
adda,
architecture,
cap'based,
class,
ducktype,
e-lang,
frameworks,
generics,
Newspeak,
oop,
soa,
subtype,
supertype,
type cluster,
value'type
editor's uncluttered ascii mode
12.26: adde/ascii mode:
news:
"( Many developers want ASCII-based editors,
in which case the syntactic clutter of
varying annotations
can rapidly become overwhelming. )
--
. adde makes it easier to use graphics
and other coded features,
by folding in code like html does,
but, for the sake of ascii tools,
it also needs to optionally provide
a file system that removes clutter
by putting the code into
files separate from the ascii .
. after modification by a foreign editor
the adde editor needs a way to know
how to merge the code with the text .
. for this it can use ascii bookmarks
which follow the head-body pattern:
their title indicates what they represent
and they have a pointer into the code file
showing where the body of code is
that implements that graphic .
. if adde finds a modified ascii file,
it checks for missing bookmarks
in order to delete the corresponding bodies .
. the code file is ascii too, of course,
but none of the words are about content
rather they give details of graphics .
. a foreign editor can see
the body of any given bookmark
by searching for the bookmark's pointer
within the code file .
. assuming that any given project folder
will have numerous text files
that may all need ascii-code separation,
one simple way to manage this separation
is to put all the code files
in a subfolder named code;
so that they can have
exactly the same name as the
ascii files they belong to;
so, if working on file: ./x,
--[the ./ means current folder ]--
then a search in ./code/x
will find the body of a bookmark .
news:
"( Many developers want ASCII-based editors,
in which case the syntactic clutter of
varying annotations
can rapidly become overwhelming. )
--
. adde makes it easier to use graphics
and other coded features,
by folding in code like html does,
but, for the sake of ascii tools,
it also needs to optionally provide
a file system that removes clutter
by putting the code into
files separate from the ascii .
. after modification by a foreign editor
the adde editor needs a way to know
how to merge the code with the text .
. for this it can use ascii bookmarks
which follow the head-body pattern:
their title indicates what they represent
and they have a pointer into the code file
showing where the body of code is
that implements that graphic .
. if adde finds a modified ascii file,
it checks for missing bookmarks
in order to delete the corresponding bodies .
. the code file is ascii too, of course,
but none of the words are about content
rather they give details of graphics .
. a foreign editor can see
the body of any given bookmark
by searching for the bookmark's pointer
within the code file .
. assuming that any given project folder
will have numerous text files
that may all need ascii-code separation,
one simple way to manage this separation
is to put all the code files
in a subfolder named code;
so that they can have
exactly the same name as the
ascii files they belong to;
so, if working on file: ./x,
--[the ./ means current folder ]--
then a search in ./code/x
will find the body of a bookmark .
Labels:
adde,
filesystem
2010-12-30
optional ducktyping
adda/oop/optional ducktyping:
12.28: syntax:
. instead of optional typing,
what about optional ducktyping?
. the easy way to declare a local
is to have it's first use describe it's type;
ie, its declaration can double as its first use;
eg, v.t -- declares "(v) to be of type"(t);
and thereafter, the var's type ext is optional;
eg, v -- the var whose full name is v.t .
. in the case of ducktyping,
the first use has the null type;
eg, ( var. ) -- the dot at the end
assures the parser that you didn't
forget to specify the var's type;
rather, you want a ducktype compiled;
ie, the parser is to find the list of
operations that were applied to that var,
and declare that to be the var's interface;
eg, f(var.); g(var) .
-- that says var is a ducktype,
and its interface is: f(), g() .
12.28, 12.30: other:
. how are typed and ducktyped obj's interacting?
both {types, ducktypes} have type.tags;
but whereas a ducktyped object
carries the type.tag with its value,
the statically typed var stores its tag
in the local symbol table
of the subprogram where it resides;
ie, the symbol table storing a ducktyped var
will declare its type as null,
meaning to be delivered at run time .
. the type.tag is a pointer to the var's type mgt
which will have a dictionary of operations .
. during run time, the ducktype's type mgt is then
checked for having all the expected operations .
# a typed obj assigned to a ducktype:
needs to be wrapped in a type.tagged box,
ie, ducktyped obj = (value, type.tag);
and statically typed obj = (value) .
# a ducktyped obj assigned to a typed obj:
needs to be unboxed before assignment
(the type.tag is compared to the destination's expected type;
and, if compatable, the type.tag is stripped out,
and the remaining value assigned).
. the assigned ducktyped obj
then still virtually has the same type.tag,
only its statically in the symbol table
rather than dynamically beside its value .
review of the current stacking system:
. static types can help efficiency:
if a parameter is statically typed,
then the type's mgt can assist in
the typical amount of stack space
needed by the union of its variants
otherwise, the system can only plan on stacking
# a ptr to trailer (local heap); or,
# a ptr to readonly .
12.30: binary operations (biops):
. just like (statically) typed var's,
ducktyping can involve class clustering
where a biop's arg's can be ducktypes;
in these cases, the run-time is checking
that both arg's have a common supertype .
. an extension of that idea is where
any number of arg's can be accommodated:
# by checking all for a common supertype;
# by checking every arg's type for the presence of
a function with a compatible signature .
12.28: syntax:
. instead of optional typing,
what about optional ducktyping?
. the easy way to declare a local
is to have it's first use describe it's type;
ie, its declaration can double as its first use;
eg, v.t -- declares "(v) to be of type"(t);
and thereafter, the var's type ext is optional;
eg, v -- the var whose full name is v.t .
. in the case of ducktyping,
the first use has the null type;
eg, ( var. ) -- the dot at the end
assures the parser that you didn't
forget to specify the var's type;
rather, you want a ducktype compiled;
ie, the parser is to find the list of
operations that were applied to that var,
and declare that to be the var's interface;
eg, f(var.); g(var) .
-- that says var is a ducktype,
and its interface is: f(), g() .
12.28, 12.30: other:
. how are typed and ducktyped obj's interacting?
both {types, ducktypes} have type.tags;
but whereas a ducktyped object
carries the type.tag with its value,
the statically typed var stores its tag
in the local symbol table
of the subprogram where it resides;
ie, the symbol table storing a ducktyped var
will declare its type as null,
meaning to be delivered at run time .
. the type.tag is a pointer to the var's type mgt
which will have a dictionary of operations .
. during run time, the ducktype's type mgt is then
checked for having all the expected operations .
# a typed obj assigned to a ducktype:
needs to be wrapped in a type.tagged box,
ie, ducktyped obj = (value, type.tag);
and statically typed obj = (value) .
# a ducktyped obj assigned to a typed obj:
needs to be unboxed before assignment
(the type.tag is compared to the destination's expected type;
and, if compatable, the type.tag is stripped out,
and the remaining value assigned).
. the assigned ducktyped obj
then still virtually has the same type.tag,
only its statically in the symbol table
rather than dynamically beside its value .
review of the current stacking system:
. static types can help efficiency:
if a parameter is statically typed,
then the type's mgt can assist in
the typical amount of stack space
needed by the union of its variants
otherwise, the system can only plan on stacking
# a ptr to trailer (local heap); or,
# a ptr to readonly .
12.30: binary operations (biops):
. just like (statically) typed var's,
ducktyping can involve class clustering
where a biop's arg's can be ducktypes;
in these cases, the run-time is checking
that both arg's have a common supertype .
. an extension of that idea is where
any number of arg's can be accommodated:
# by checking all for a common supertype;
# by checking every arg's type for the presence of
a function with a compatible signature .
vector literals syntax
12.28: adda/dstr/vector literals:
. as with the declare's syntax
the opening angle brackets of the
vector literal formed with angle brackets
could be distinguished from less-than
by following it with a dot .
. ascii tokens are useful even with unicode
because, keyboard's can quickly dish up ascii .
. the parser converts ascii to unicode's:
less-than & dot -> opening vector bracket (U+27E8)
--. the closing pair is: U+27E9 .
related trivia:
Miscellaneous Mathematical Symbols:
U+27C0 ... U+27EF, U+2980 ... U+29FF .
'Miscellaneous Technical' 2300 ... 23FF:
(has a left-pointing angle bracket U+2329) .
--. ascii codes for {math relations, brackets}:
U+003C Less-than sign
U+003E Greater-than sign .
. unicodes that mac os x supports .
. as with the declare's syntax
the opening angle brackets of the
vector literal formed with angle brackets
could be distinguished from less-than
by following it with a dot .
. ascii tokens are useful even with unicode
because, keyboard's can quickly dish up ascii .
. the parser converts ascii to unicode's:
less-than & dot -> opening vector bracket (U+27E8)
--. the closing pair is: U+27E9 .
related trivia:
Miscellaneous Mathematical Symbols:
U+27C0 ... U+27EF, U+2980 ... U+29FF .
'Miscellaneous Technical' 2300 ... 23FF:
(has a left-pointing angle bracket U+2329) .
--. ascii codes for {math relations, brackets}:
U+003C Less-than sign
U+003E Greater-than sign .
. unicodes that mac os x supports .
2010-12-29
std input and gui interaction drivers
12.27: adda/arch/std`input:
. in my idealized expression of the mvc pattern,
the designers of apps should never have to
program the details of the user's gui;
they simply write to data structures,
and the user`agents have their favorite ways of
expressing structures graphically;
but what if the app designer
wants to contribute new ways of
graphical interaction ?
. such gui drivers shouldn't get direct access
to the mouse and keyboard (input events);
instead, like unix is designed,
drivers get gui events from std`input;
and, the user`agent is free to
feed the gui driver either the actual input events
or the user`agent's version of input events .
[12.29: for modularity:
. the gui driver's usefulness to some users
may depend on the user`agent's ability to
filter the user's input,
or simulating it with an algorithm;
eg, an adaptation for those with the shakes
might be to filter duplicate inputs .
adde plug-in's:
. the general way to develope the gui
is for adda, the compiler,
to be aware of plug-in's for adde, the editor;
a gui driver is associated with a typemark,
and then when adde is displaying
items of that type,
it lets the associated gui driver
decide how inputs translate into
modifying a value of that type .
. there can also be event-triggered gui drivers
(vs triggered by accessing a certain type)
eg, a selection lasso driver
would be triggered by a mouse-down drag,
and instead of stopping at mouse-up,
it would keep accumulating selection rectangles,
until, say, the enter key was pressed .]
. in my idealized expression of the mvc pattern,
the designers of apps should never have to
program the details of the user's gui;
they simply write to data structures,
and the user`agents have their favorite ways of
expressing structures graphically;
but what if the app designer
wants to contribute new ways of
graphical interaction ?
. such gui drivers shouldn't get direct access
to the mouse and keyboard (input events);
instead, like unix is designed,
drivers get gui events from std`input;
and, the user`agent is free to
feed the gui driver either the actual input events
or the user`agent's version of input events .
[12.29: for modularity:
. the gui driver's usefulness to some users
may depend on the user`agent's ability to
filter the user's input,
or simulating it with an algorithm;
eg, an adaptation for those with the shakes
might be to filter duplicate inputs .
adde plug-in's:
. the general way to develope the gui
is for adda, the compiler,
to be aware of plug-in's for adde, the editor;
a gui driver is associated with a typemark,
and then when adde is displaying
items of that type,
it lets the associated gui driver
decide how inputs translate into
modifying a value of that type .
. there can also be event-triggered gui drivers
(vs triggered by accessing a certain type)
eg, a selection lasso driver
would be triggered by a mouse-down drag,
and instead of stopping at mouse-up,
it would keep accumulating selection rectangles,
until, say, the enter key was pressed .]
declare block syntax
12.28: adda/cstr/declare:
. with a declare block represented by
this: .(BODY)
-- a dot-prefixed parenthetical --
it's immediately confused with a
type description literal;
instead, the syntax should be
a special case of function literal:
(.(x) BODY)
by just having a null parameter:
(. BODY);
function literals will eval
even when parameterized
-- if complete defaults are given
and the literal is not quoted --
and can thereby double as a declare block .
. the arg list can also be a
symbol returning type record:
(.myrec BODY);
[12.29: the point being that
anywhere a record def' literal can go,
a symbol for the same should be allowed;
but what about the syntax for functions?
f(x).returntype
-- that sets a precedent for
parenthetical literals not (yet) being
replaceable by a symbol;
but in that case,
the ().type pattern is there to
intuitively identify a function
-- f(x) = name & parenthetical literal .
. when expressing the function's arg type as a typemark,
readers need to be guided as to whether
a symbol is a {typemark, local param's name};
this can be done by using both
the paren'literal for "(this a function decl)
and the dot-prefix on the symbol
for "(this is a typemark):
eg, f(.typemark).returntype .
conclusion:
. the original (.(x) BODY) syntax
is modeled after ( var.type )
but puts the .(x) at the enclosure's opening
to show that it's typing the enclosure itself,
and not something the enclosure is qualifying;
it says:
this enclosure is a function of this arg, x,
eval'able when x is instantiated .
. the idea of typed enclosures representing sets
comes from:
# set-builder notation:
variously syntaxed as {x: body}, or {x|body}
either of which is generally ambiguous
given popular meanings for colon and div .
# types as sets of values:
to type a var without init'ing it
is to say it currently represents
a set of values .
. reasons why that syntax can't be
(body).(x):
# parameters are intuitively expected
at the beginning, as is done in math:
{x: body}, or {x|body};
# (b).(x) is confusable with a type literal:
one expressing a function returning record .]
. with a declare block represented by
this: .(BODY)
-- a dot-prefixed parenthetical --
it's immediately confused with a
type description literal;
instead, the syntax should be
a special case of function literal:
(.(x) BODY)
by just having a null parameter:
(. BODY);
function literals will eval
even when parameterized
-- if complete defaults are given
and the literal is not quoted --
and can thereby double as a declare block .
. the arg list can also be a
symbol returning type record:
(.myrec BODY);
[12.29: the point being that
anywhere a record def' literal can go,
a symbol for the same should be allowed;
but what about the syntax for functions?
f(x).returntype
-- that sets a precedent for
parenthetical literals not (yet) being
replaceable by a symbol;
but in that case,
the ().type pattern is there to
intuitively identify a function
-- f(x) = name & parenthetical literal .
. when expressing the function's arg type as a typemark,
readers need to be guided as to whether
a symbol is a {typemark, local param's name};
this can be done by using both
the paren'literal for "(this a function decl)
and the dot-prefix on the symbol
for "(this is a typemark):
eg, f(.typemark).returntype .
conclusion:
. the original (.(x) BODY) syntax
is modeled after ( var.type )
but puts the .(x) at the enclosure's opening
to show that it's typing the enclosure itself,
and not something the enclosure is qualifying;
it says:
this enclosure is a function of this arg, x,
eval'able when x is instantiated .
. the idea of typed enclosures representing sets
comes from:
# set-builder notation:
variously syntaxed as {x: body}, or {x|body}
either of which is generally ambiguous
given popular meanings for colon and div .
# types as sets of values:
to type a var without init'ing it
is to say it currently represents
a set of values .
. reasons why that syntax can't be
(body).(x):
# parameters are intuitively expected
at the beginning, as is done in math:
{x: body}, or {x|body};
# (b).(x) is confusable with a type literal:
one expressing a function returning record .]
newspeak for Strongtalk
12.26: adda/arch/newspeak for strongtalk:
[12.29:
Bracha, a proponent of pluggable types,
was concerned that it weakened security
to rely on datatypes rather than
use oop`ducktyping everywhere .
. datatypes make several leaps of faith:
# the compiler has correctly analyzed
the program's compliance to type compatibility;
# the compiler's optimizations
still maintain this compliance;
# changes to the environment don't bedevil
assumptions required by this compliance .]
. Bracha, a proponent of Strongtalk
(smalltalk with pluggable types)
has moved on to Newspeak
but expects a pluggable typesystem
can be integrated later .
. Newspeak's most notable difference
seems to be capability-based security (cap's);
let's review what that does
compared to oop's ducktyping .
. oop's ducktyping calls turned
anything like f(x)
into x`type-mgt( operation:f, arg:x),
and x's type-mgt provides this service
for anyone who asks;
ie, if the current account can use x,
then any app running under that account
has permission to use x;
[12.29: whereas,
cap's are object-specific permissions:
an object accepts a call only if
the caller possesses a permission that
# specifies that object, and
# doesn't preclude the requested operation .
. a process starts out with no cap's
except those needed to remain functional:
it can accept arg's, return results,
and modify its own local mem allotment .
. other capabilities require
special permission provided by employers
(the user, admin, or os kernel).]
12.26: caller id:
. cap's are giving each app their own id,
so that cap'based calls would also involve
the caller id; [12.29:
well,
it includes the concept of caller id;
like so:
cap's are awarded to particular id's,
and they are non-transferable;
so, then cap's are essentially a tuple:
(caller id, allowed object, allowed operations) .]
12.27: adda`plans:
. cap's can be controlled by
the run-time supervisor
instead of the current object's type-mgt .
. after the user has set limits on each app;
these become part of process records
(owned by supervision's task mgt),
and all attempts by a process
to communicate with others,
becomes a function of the capabilities:
eg, instead of asking to access the file system,
a process says things like,
"( let me modify the portion of filesystem
pointed at by my process record's writableFiles cap' .)
"( let me read all files within
my process record's readableFiles cap' ).
[12.29:
Bracha, a proponent of pluggable types,
was concerned that it weakened security
to rely on datatypes rather than
use oop`ducktyping everywhere .
. datatypes make several leaps of faith:
# the compiler has correctly analyzed
the program's compliance to type compatibility;
# the compiler's optimizations
still maintain this compliance;
# changes to the environment don't bedevil
assumptions required by this compliance .]
. Bracha, a proponent of Strongtalk
(smalltalk with pluggable types)
has moved on to Newspeak
but expects a pluggable typesystem
can be integrated later .
. Newspeak's most notable difference
seems to be capability-based security (cap's);
let's review what that does
compared to oop's ducktyping .
. oop's ducktyping calls turned
anything like f(x)
into x`type-mgt( operation:f, arg:x),
and x's type-mgt provides this service
for anyone who asks;
ie, if the current account can use x,
then any app running under that account
has permission to use x;
[12.29: whereas,
cap's are object-specific permissions:
an object accepts a call only if
the caller possesses a permission that
# specifies that object, and
# doesn't preclude the requested operation .
. a process starts out with no cap's
except those needed to remain functional:
it can accept arg's, return results,
and modify its own local mem allotment .
. other capabilities require
special permission provided by employers
(the user, admin, or os kernel).]
12.26: caller id:
. cap's are giving each app their own id,
so that cap'based calls would also involve
the caller id; [12.29:
well,
it includes the concept of caller id;
like so:
cap's are awarded to particular id's,
and they are non-transferable;
so, then cap's are essentially a tuple:
(caller id, allowed object, allowed operations) .]
12.27: adda`plans:
. cap's can be controlled by
the run-time supervisor
instead of the current object's type-mgt .
. after the user has set limits on each app;
these become part of process records
(owned by supervision's task mgt),
and all attempts by a process
to communicate with others,
becomes a function of the capabilities:
eg, instead of asking to access the file system,
a process says things like,
"( let me modify the portion of filesystem
pointed at by my process record's writableFiles cap' .)
"( let me read all files within
my process record's readableFiles cap' ).
2010-12-27
Gilad Bracha's pluggable types
adda/gilad`pluggable types
summary:
12.26: varieties of encapsulation?
Typical language semantics depend on the type system
(e.g., casts, overloading, accessibility).
By eliminating this dependency,
we can make our languages more modular.
Class-based encapsulation
(relies critically on complex and fragile
typecheckers and verifiers)
-- very popular, but inherently less secure than
object-based encapsulation
(enforced only by context-free grammar).
Typecheckers are tricky and often buggy;
whereas, parsers are well understood.
--. optional typing simplifies language design,
to the benefit of the system as a whole.
12.27: understanding the concept:
. how can types be optional in smalltalk
when in fact smalltalk has an inheritance hierarchy?
aren't oop classes acting as types?
. oop typing is by definition "(optional);
because, it depends only dynamic typechecking .
. manditory typing (vs optional) is when
the code won't compile until after
the static typechecking system has verified
(by analyzing declared types and compatible assignments)
that any future object can handle
any of the messages they may be sent;
whereas,
smaltalk's oop never assumes future knowledge;
rather, every function call consists of
sending the object the name of the message,
and then that object can verify for itself
-- before accepting the current call --
whether it can handle a message of that name .
. the main idea of pluggable types
is that while smalltalk oop's
dynamic typechecking is a great idea,
static analysis has additional value
-- both can coexist together .
. a lang's type declarations are optional
when the lang's compiler can generate code
regardless of whether
the type declarations exist .
. type declarations are pluggable when
when developer tools support multiple
static type declaration analyzers;
a test run consists of
first sending the code to the current analyzers;
if there are no warnings,
then the code is sent to the compiler .
. given some warnings, the developer can still
opt to compile the code anyway,
which will run until at least until caught by
any run-in's with dynamic typechecking .
12.11 ... 12.12: news.adda/gilad`pluggable types:
. I found pluggable types mentioned in
a comment on a forum where Mark S. Miller
explained why capabilities rule and ACLs drool:
"(. Gilad, in his Pluggable Types manifesto,
talks about serialization as part of his
justification for why the vm's execution
shouldn't depend on types . )
-- z-bo
"(... the software systems equivalent of
Padlipsky's The Elements of Networking Style...
demonstrating why, in the software industry,
everything we do today is moronic and monolithic.)
ppt for bracha`pluggable-types.pdf:
. static type is characteristically mandatory;
types should instead be optional;
a paradox of using type systems for
reliability and security
is that while they can
mechanically prove properties,
they are making things complex and brittle;
eg, type systems for vm and lang collide .
. persistence works best with structural typing;
whereas, nominal typing (declared by a type name )
forces the serialization
(a subsystem for persistent filing)
to separate objects from their behavior;
it can't tolerate a type's name being
associated with more than one impl' .
[12.27: well,
that's why there are class clusters,
where the type mgt declares a std format
for all member types to file their state as .]
12.12 ... 12.13: gilad's complete paper:
Gilad Is Right:
. the talk notes need backing by this paper:
pico.vub.ac.be/~wdmeuter/RDL04/papers/Bracha.pdf
(found here)
class-based encapsulation
vs object-based encapsulation ? ...
. Class based encapsulation.
class C
{ private secret.int
; public expose( c.C).int { return secret;}
} -- there is no way to know
when access to encapsulated members is allowed
without a (prohibitively costly) dynamic check.
Instead, use object-based encapsulation,
as in Smalltalk or Self .
[12.26:
. keep in mind he's talking about
merging dynamic with static typing;
object-based encapsulation? how about:
"Object-Oriented Encapsulation for Dynamically Typed Languages":
"( Encapsulation in object-oriented languages
has traditionally been based on static type systems.
As a consequence, dynamically-typed languages have
only limited support for encapsulation;
this paper is bringing encapsulation features
to dynamically typed languages.) ]
[12.27: the point of the example of
class-based encapsulation
was showing how it allowed for declaring
-- in the interface (vs class body) --
the body of an accessor
that accessed an instance var;
whereas proper interface-body separation
doesn't allow any assumptions about
what an interface entry does with privates .]
. using the assumptions of smalltalk oop,
a method can be accessed without knowing
the obj's type or class;
ie, if it doesn't support that method
then it simply returns nil,
or otherwise raise a not-supported.exception .
. overloading functions implicitly requires
nominal typing of function parameters;
not good ...
bewildered? a concrete example is strongtalk!
(originally at www.cs.ucsb.edu/projects/strongtalk)
12.26: complete text (found on his site):
Pluggable Type Systems Gilad Bracha October 17, 2004
12.26: Strongtalk`history:
Dave Griswold was frustrated with the fact that
there were still a lot of obstacles to using Smalltalk
in most kinds of production applications.
. it was still way too slow, [but simple]
had poor support for native user interfaces
(but portable)
and lacked a [static] type system,
which although it makes the language flexible,
also means large-scale software systems
are a lot harder to understand .
. by 1996 the system was transformed
by Urs Hölzle's speedy compilation technology,
and Gilad Bracha's type system for
programming-in-the-large;
but then the Java phenomenon happened;
years later, Sun finally open-sourced Strongtalk .
New repository location for Strongtalk 4 Oct 2010
new repository location on github
You will also find the first steps on a
Newspeak port on branch nsreboot.
strongtalk overview:
. the type system is not concerned with
improving execution performance,
since it is based on interface types.
Optimization requires concrete
implementation type information.
key characteristics of the Strongtalk type system are :
* allows natural Smalltalk idioms to be typechecked:
1. Separates the subtype and subclass lattices.
2. Includes parameterized types and classes.
3. Supports parametrically polymorphic messages,
with a flexible mechanism for
automatically inferring actual type parameters.
4. Supports both subtyping and type matching.
6. Provides facilities for dynamic typing.
5. Preserves the subtype relations between classes
defined by the Smalltalk metaclass hierarchy
and relates them to the types of their instances.
A protocol is a collection of message selectors
and their associated signatures;
Every class C automatically induces a protocol,
The type hierarchy is defined using protocols.
* The system provides the same kind of
reflective access to type information
as Smalltalk does to other language constructs.
Note that if a program does access
type information reflectively,
then by definition its behavior is dependent on
the type annotations in it.
Strongtalk supports two relations on types:
# Subtyping (substitutability):
an element of a subtype can be safely used
wherever an element of a supertype is expected.
# Matching (common pattern of self reference):
. Every protocol definition specifies its supertypes.
Likewise, a class definition can specify
the supertypes of its protocol.
By default, a protocol is declared to be
a subtype of its superprotocol.
summary:
12.26: varieties of encapsulation?
Typical language semantics depend on the type system
(e.g., casts, overloading, accessibility).
By eliminating this dependency,
we can make our languages more modular.
Class-based encapsulation
(relies critically on complex and fragile
typecheckers and verifiers)
-- very popular, but inherently less secure than
object-based encapsulation
(enforced only by context-free grammar).
Typecheckers are tricky and often buggy;
whereas, parsers are well understood.
--. optional typing simplifies language design,
to the benefit of the system as a whole.
12.27: understanding the concept:
. how can types be optional in smalltalk
when in fact smalltalk has an inheritance hierarchy?
aren't oop classes acting as types?
. oop typing is by definition "(optional);
because, it depends only dynamic typechecking .
. manditory typing (vs optional) is when
the code won't compile until after
the static typechecking system has verified
(by analyzing declared types and compatible assignments)
that any future object can handle
any of the messages they may be sent;
whereas,
smaltalk's oop never assumes future knowledge;
rather, every function call consists of
sending the object the name of the message,
and then that object can verify for itself
-- before accepting the current call --
whether it can handle a message of that name .
. the main idea of pluggable types
is that while smalltalk oop's
dynamic typechecking is a great idea,
static analysis has additional value
-- both can coexist together .
. a lang's type declarations are optional
when the lang's compiler can generate code
regardless of whether
the type declarations exist .
. type declarations are pluggable when
when developer tools support multiple
static type declaration analyzers;
a test run consists of
first sending the code to the current analyzers;
if there are no warnings,
then the code is sent to the compiler .
. given some warnings, the developer can still
opt to compile the code anyway,
which will run until at least until caught by
any run-in's with dynamic typechecking .
12.11 ... 12.12: news.adda/gilad`pluggable types:
. I found pluggable types mentioned in
a comment on a forum where Mark S. Miller
explained why capabilities rule and ACLs drool:
"(. Gilad, in his Pluggable Types manifesto,
talks about serialization as part of his
justification for why the vm's execution
shouldn't depend on types . )
-- z-bo
"(... the software systems equivalent of
Padlipsky's The Elements of Networking Style...
demonstrating why, in the software industry,
everything we do today is moronic and monolithic.)
ppt for bracha`pluggable-types.pdf:
. static type is characteristically mandatory;
types should instead be optional;
a paradox of using type systems for
reliability and security
is that while they can
mechanically prove properties,
they are making things complex and brittle;
eg, type systems for vm and lang collide .
. persistence works best with structural typing;
whereas, nominal typing (declared by a type name )
forces the serialization
(a subsystem for persistent filing)
to separate objects from their behavior;
it can't tolerate a type's name being
associated with more than one impl' .
[12.27: well,
that's why there are class clusters,
where the type mgt declares a std format
for all member types to file their state as .]
12.12 ... 12.13: gilad's complete paper:
Gilad Is Right:
. the talk notes need backing by this paper:
pico.vub.ac.be/~wdmeuter/RDL04/papers/Bracha.pdf
(found here)
class-based encapsulation
vs object-based encapsulation ? ...
. Class based encapsulation.
class C
{ private secret.int
; public expose( c.C).int { return secret;}
} -- there is no way to know
when access to encapsulated members is allowed
without a (prohibitively costly) dynamic check.
Instead, use object-based encapsulation,
as in Smalltalk or Self .
[12.26:
. keep in mind he's talking about
merging dynamic with static typing;
object-based encapsulation? how about:
"Object-Oriented Encapsulation for Dynamically Typed Languages":
"( Encapsulation in object-oriented languages
has traditionally been based on static type systems.
As a consequence, dynamically-typed languages have
only limited support for encapsulation;
this paper is bringing encapsulation features
to dynamically typed languages.) ]
[12.27: the point of the example of
class-based encapsulation
was showing how it allowed for declaring
-- in the interface (vs class body) --
the body of an accessor
that accessed an instance var;
whereas proper interface-body separation
doesn't allow any assumptions about
what an interface entry does with privates .]
. using the assumptions of smalltalk oop,
a method can be accessed without knowing
the obj's type or class;
ie, if it doesn't support that method
then it simply returns nil,
or otherwise raise a not-supported.exception .
. overloading functions implicitly requires
nominal typing of function parameters;
not good ...
bewildered? a concrete example is strongtalk!
(originally at www.cs.ucsb.edu/projects/strongtalk)
12.26: complete text (found on his site):
Pluggable Type Systems Gilad Bracha October 17, 2004
12.26: Strongtalk`history:
Dave Griswold was frustrated with the fact that
there were still a lot of obstacles to using Smalltalk
in most kinds of production applications.
. it was still way too slow, [but simple]
had poor support for native user interfaces
(but portable)
and lacked a [static] type system,
which although it makes the language flexible,
also means large-scale software systems
are a lot harder to understand .
. by 1996 the system was transformed
by Urs Hölzle's speedy compilation technology,
and Gilad Bracha's type system for
programming-in-the-large;
but then the Java phenomenon happened;
years later, Sun finally open-sourced Strongtalk .
New repository location for Strongtalk 4 Oct 2010
new repository location on github
You will also find the first steps on a
Newspeak port on branch nsreboot.
strongtalk overview:
. the type system is not concerned with
improving execution performance,
since it is based on interface types.
Optimization requires concrete
implementation type information.
key characteristics of the Strongtalk type system are :
* allows natural Smalltalk idioms to be typechecked:
1. Separates the subtype and subclass lattices.
2. Includes parameterized types and classes.
3. Supports parametrically polymorphic messages,
with a flexible mechanism for
automatically inferring actual type parameters.
4. Supports both subtyping and type matching.
6. Provides facilities for dynamic typing.
5. Preserves the subtype relations between classes
defined by the Smalltalk metaclass hierarchy
and relates them to the types of their instances.
A protocol is a collection of message selectors
and their associated signatures;
Every class C automatically induces a protocol,
The type hierarchy is defined using protocols.
* The system provides the same kind of
reflective access to type information
as Smalltalk does to other language constructs.
Note that if a program does access
type information reflectively,
then by definition its behavior is dependent on
the type annotations in it.
Strongtalk supports two relations on types:
# Subtyping (substitutability):
an element of a subtype can be safely used
wherever an element of a supertype is expected.
# Matching (common pattern of self reference):
. Every protocol definition specifies its supertypes.
Likewise, a class definition can specify
the supertypes of its protocol.
By default, a protocol is declared to be
a subtype of its superprotocol.
Labels:
adda,
architecture,
oop,
type
2010-12-25
managing capabilities without encryption
12.7: adda/cstr/managing capabilities without encryption:
. in a read of capability-based security
I wondered if there was some way to
have capability enforcement
without having to encrypt all the shared pointers .
. related ideas include:
# Singularity's faster task switching
done by using ref's to shared mem'
instead of passing copies between modules;
# how to use pointers to shared resources
so that even though 2 concurrent sharers
were both active at different processors,
only one active sharer at a time
would have a useful link to the shared resource .
sketch of a possible design:
. a process can never reach out directly,
but is always accessing things via
pointers located in their header,
and only the supervisor can modify this header;
eg, the task scheduler .
. it's not enough to have possession of a pointer,
you've got to have a supervisor
copy it to your header;
so, it's like encryption,
in that it requires an authorization .
layers for when bugs happen:
. encrypted cap'pointers are being
another level of security; [12.25:
. cap'based is supposed to include
the soa idea:
. bugs are going to get into the system,
but in a software system that
connected it's modules
the same way https connects computers,
then it wouldn't matter bugs had invaded;
because each of the components is
being separately guarded by modularity
(not allowing direct access to state)
and is working only with ID'd clients
(not servicing anonymous agents).
. the idea of unencrypted header pointers
is assuming that
the system's runtime can be secured
which is not likely
on today's monolithic OS's .]
. in a read of capability-based security
I wondered if there was some way to
have capability enforcement
without having to encrypt all the shared pointers .
. related ideas include:
# Singularity's faster task switching
done by using ref's to shared mem'
instead of passing copies between modules;
# how to use pointers to shared resources
so that even though 2 concurrent sharers
were both active at different processors,
only one active sharer at a time
would have a useful link to the shared resource .
sketch of a possible design:
. a process can never reach out directly,
but is always accessing things via
pointers located in their header,
and only the supervisor can modify this header;
eg, the task scheduler .
. it's not enough to have possession of a pointer,
you've got to have a supervisor
copy it to your header;
so, it's like encryption,
in that it requires an authorization .
layers for when bugs happen:
. encrypted cap'pointers are being
another level of security; [12.25:
. cap'based is supposed to include
the soa idea:
. bugs are going to get into the system,
but in a software system that
connected it's modules
the same way https connects computers,
then it wouldn't matter bugs had invaded;
because each of the components is
being separately guarded by modularity
(not allowing direct access to state)
and is working only with ID'd clients
(not servicing anonymous agents).
. the idea of unencrypted header pointers
is assuming that
the system's runtime can be secured
which is not likely
on today's monolithic OS's .]
2010-12-23
icons of the alphabet
12.23: adds/icons of the alphabet:
. abc's look like the very basic mechanisms
whose names begin with such letters:
Angle(A is icon of angle arc between hinge plates)
Bisect(graphical counting or dividing),
Circumfrence, Diameter,
Extend (greek E means summation)
Front (arrow points at front surface of a drafting view
-- vs the top surface),
Gyration (revolving starts from right angle),
Hinge (H can be plates hinged),
Iatric(healed, parts assembled
-- I is a clocking of H)
Join(J has a hook for joining)
Kaleidoscope (K shows both V and V's mirror image)
Ligature (bonding of multiple indep'dimensions
-- symbolized by L, a right angle).
Multiply (M is a clocking of E, summation)
Not(N is the same shape as set`not: ~)
Oscillation (O is loop like cycles, oscillations),
Post-Oscillation or Product
(P is icon of dropping out of a loop)
Quality (what's under Oscillation? its basis or control)
Radical (Oscillation's side affects)
Specialization (S looks like yin-yang formations
-- specializing in complementary differences)
Top (arrow points at top surface of a drafting view)
Union (U looks like a collecting cup)
Vacillation (V is side view of wave, VVVV)
Wall (W is a counter-clocking of E, summation
-- stop additions)
Xiphoid (Greek xiphos: sword)
Yes (what's under Vacillation?
-- basis or control of V, energy)
Zero (Z is a clocking of N, not(this): not anything)
. abc's look like the very basic mechanisms
whose names begin with such letters:
Angle(A is icon of angle arc between hinge plates)
Bisect(graphical counting or dividing),
Circumfrence, Diameter,
Extend (greek E means summation)
Front (arrow points at front surface of a drafting view
-- vs the top surface),
Gyration (revolving starts from right angle),
Hinge (H can be plates hinged),
Iatric(healed, parts assembled
-- I is a clocking of H)
Join(J has a hook for joining)
Kaleidoscope (K shows both V and V's mirror image)
Ligature (bonding of multiple indep'dimensions
-- symbolized by L, a right angle).
Multiply (M is a clocking of E, summation)
Not(N is the same shape as set`not: ~)
Oscillation (O is loop like cycles, oscillations),
Post-Oscillation or Product
(P is icon of dropping out of a loop)
Quality (what's under Oscillation? its basis or control)
Radical (Oscillation's side affects)
Specialization (S looks like yin-yang formations
-- specializing in complementary differences)
Top (arrow points at top surface of a drafting view)
Union (U looks like a collecting cup)
Vacillation (V is side view of wave, VVVV)
Wall (W is a counter-clocking of E, summation
-- stop additions)
Xiphoid (Greek xiphos: sword)
Yes (what's under Vacillation?
-- basis or control of V, energy)
Zero (Z is a clocking of N, not(this): not anything)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
