2011-07-30

Ousterhout's dichotomy

7.1: news.adda/Ousterhout's dichotomy:
. John Ousterhout, designer of Tcl,
noticed that high-level programming languages
tend to fall into two groups,
"system programming languages"
and "scripting languages".
[ie you can't have a language that is
optimal for both .
. in defence of that claim,
pypy tried to have a system language Rpython
that was as much as possible like
Python, the scripting lang;
because they wanted
a self-hosting python compiler
ie, one written in python instead of c .
[7.30: like adda,
Rpython is designed to translate into c
for the purpose of avoiding c:
system programmers can use Rpython
yet still take advantage of c compilers .]
. the closest Rpython could get to python
is a subset of it that added static typing;
because, some features that support
coder productivity
are antithetical to features that support
algorithm efficiency .
. Ousterhout was likely pointing out that
scripting lang efficiency was not so important;
because, scripts are glue for
subprograms of sufficient size,
such that most of the run time
is spent in the parts defined by the system lang .
7.30: web:
D. Ancona, M. Ancona, A Cuni, and N. Matsakis.
RPython: a Step Towards Reconciling
Dynamically and Statically Typed OO Languages.
In OOPSLA 2007 Proceedings and Companion, DLS'07:
Proceedings of the 2007 Symposium on
Dynamic Languages, pages 53-64. ACM, 2007(pdf)
. an approach that attempts to preserve
the flexibility of Python,
while still allowing for efficient execution
is limiting the use of
the more dynamic features of Python
to an initial, bootstrapping phase.
This phase is used to construct
a final RPython (Restricted Python) program
that is actually executed.
RPython is a proper subset of Python,
is statically typed,
and does not allow dynamic modification
of class or method definitions;
however, it can still take advantage of
Python features such as mixins and
first-class methods and classes.
This paper presents an overview of RPython,
including its design and its translation to
both CLI and JVM bytecode.
We show how the bootstrapping phase can be
used to implement advanced features,
like extensible classes and generative programming.
   

No comments:

Post a Comment